Strike One: whoever does not complete their assignment, they are not aloud to eat food that Friday.
Strike two: for whoever forgets to complete their assignment twice, they get their laptop taken away by Mr. Morone and they have to bring the food and they are also not aloud to eat it.
Strike Three: you get double the work.
Strike Four: lastly if you forget to do your assignment, you get a zero for participation and there names will be written down on this website, so Mr. Morone knows who the person is.
One must stand and sing a song
Weak 1 jobs
Group leader Mitchell
Person C Nick
Summarizer alex
Quotation finder mike Ryan
Weak 2 jobs
Group leader Mike
Person B Michell
person C Ryan Alex Ryan didn't do it
person D Nick
1. The main characters are Doll,Bells, Queen, Feife, Welsh, Stein, Storm, Dale. They are all tough strong willed people who are in the C for charlie squad for a reason, they all treat each other tough like in order to succeed. Doll acts like a tough guy and is like a rebel. Bells was an army engineer in the philippenes and got re-signed. Queen is some one who is very strong. Feife is kind of a coward and Welsh is kind of a strange person. Stein is the captain of the squad. Storm is the cook and takes pride in his work. Dale is one of the cooks who found the thompsons.
2 quotations Mike Tudisco
At any rate, the best way to be injured was to have a wound so bad that you almost die, one that would keep you sick long enough for the
war to be over, but not bad enough to be crippled by.
The explosion itself actually – could be considered the apex from which the line turned down to the bottom and discharge, their secret goal.
In the end, C for Charlie saw three men die in the aid station.
They had crossed a line, they were wounded men, and everyone knew they were different.
And one man, word had it, had his face smashed in by a helmet blown from the head of some man in the barge.
Person 3-Nick Zevits
1. How would you react if you saw someone die right in front of you? What about if you had to kill someone?
Answer: "I would be scared that I might also be shot and be thankful it was not me who died. I would just kill the person because it is my job, and that person is trying to kill me."
2. Do you think it was really worth it for Doll to steal the pistol, why or why not?
Answer: "I think it was good for Doll to steal the pistol because it might help him and his company if they get surprised attacked so he can pull out the pistol easily instead of having to get his rifle."
3. If you found the Japanese burial site, what would you do? Would you let the other soldiers do what they did?
Answer: "If I found the Japanese burial site, I would explore it and see what I find. I would not have let Queen and the other soldiers disrespect the burial ground the way they did."
4. How would you react if your hand was cut off from a missile fragment, and the medics did not really care?
Answer: "I would curse at the medics, and then tell them to throw the hand away because I would hate to look at my own hand that was cut off."
5. Would you have stolen the guns from the tent? Why or why not?
Answer: "I would have stolen the guns from the tent because it is only 7 machine guns and 6 rifles. Also, it could help my company out if we ever got caught in a battle."
Alex Falzarano
The first book club meeting, in my opinion, was a mix between conversation and arguments. Throughout the second half of the conversation, after we settled down and actually started to do what we were supposed to do, everything went relatively smooth. Some of our answers to the questions that Nick gave us were a little choppy. We discussed the main characters in the book, and what their characteristics were in the beginning of the book. In addition, we discussed our opinion on the some of the horrifying obstacles the characters faced in the first 100 hundred pages of the book. Some of the questions that we were asked were, what would your reaction be if you had just killed someone? Another question that we were asked was, if you had found the Japanese burial site, what would you have done. Would you have let the other soldier do what they did? Despite our minor setbacks in the beginning of the meeting, this first meeting went relatively smooth once we got going. Hopefully by the next meeting everyone will have read there assigned amount of pages, and the next meeting will run smoothly with no interruptions.
Ryan Patti- Quotations
1. "Alright, fuck face! Where's that fucking platoon roster I told you to fix up for me!"(pg 32)
2. Even the army itself understood this about them then wounded, and had made special despensations for their newly accquired honorly status.(pg 47)
3. "Fuck duties!"(pg 60)
4. It had stopped raining when they were in the jungle. But they hadn't known it.(pg 79)
5. Finally it would be a day that they take up their lives once more.(pg 90)
Week 2 discussion leader Mike 1 The grade level is 18 and up. They use the f word a lot and has a few hard to understand words.
The book uses modern language.
Nick Zevits-Person D (Summarizer)
The second book club meeting went a little better than the first. at the beginning of the meeting, we were mostly on task and everyone was listening to the person speaking. This was the first meeting we had to enforce the group's rules. Ryan forgot his homework for the second meeting so we had to take his food away and now he has to do his work for this past week and next week for the third meeting. Noise was not a bad problem at the first half of the meeting, and everyone was contributing to the group. I thought the group was improving a lot better than the last meeting, until everyone was done with sharing their jobs and started typing.
Everyone started fooling around and nothing was getting accomplished. Only one person was able to type their part at a time so everyone was waiting for the person to finish. Since everyone was talking and fooling around, the person did not type as fast as they could and kept everyone else waiting. The only thing that did improve was the commitment of the group members. A lot of food was brought this friday compared to the last friday. It was like a feast with all of our food we had. I hope next week the group picks up their acts including me and hope it goes a lot better than the previous meetings.
Person C- Alex Falzarano
1. Like Fife, would you regret enlisting in World War two, just because you did not want look like a coward in front of your country. Why or Why not? No because I would want to be loyal to my country.
2. Do you think you would have to courage to keep on walking even though you were being fired at by an unknown position, or would you start crawling, like some in the soldiers in Charlie Company did? I would want to craw because I would not want to get shot.
3. When Peale got injured, if you were him, would you want to eventually come back into the war, or not? Yes because you would get drafted back into the war.
4. If you were one of the soldiers who had saw what the Japanese did to the 2 solders from George company, would that make you want to fight harder or no? yes.
5. If you had saw a dead body with a Thompson machine on to of it would you take it why or why not? Yes because it is for the teams benefit.
Week 3
Alex Falzarano person A
The chapter that we read this week had a very sad and dramatic mood. During this chapter, many people of Charlie Company died because of Japanese mortar emplacements, and small arms fire from hidden locations. Bead, one of the main characters in the book, died by getting hit by fragment from a mortal shell. Throughout this chapter everyone was depressed, and constantly thinking about how they might die in any second of their attack on hill 209.
Mike Tudisco Questions
1 What do you think would be the hardest part of serving in the army?
Trying to face the fact that you could die.
2 Why do you think everyone in the army needs to act so “macho”?
They don’t want to be made fun of.
3 What was Doll’s reason for volunteering to go tell Stein that the Japanese were leaving the ridge even thou it was suicide?.
Because he killed someone and had a adrenalin rush.
4 Why did Fife wish he was crazy?
He would have been kicked out of the army.
5 What does Welsh saying, “property, property, all for property”, mean?
Everything is done for land or money.
MItchell raver questions
1. Would you shoot Welsh to put him out of his misery
No, i would not want to kill someone i am friends with
2. Would you disagree with the Captains orders?
Yes, if they are really stupid
3. How would you feel if someone that was only friends with you died?
I would feel terrible and feel for him
4. How would you react to someone getting shot in the war?
I would kind of move on but still be sad
5. Would you proud to be recommended to go up a rank?
Yes because i feel like i have done a good job and helped a lot
Nick Zevits Person B
Pg. 190, Paragraph 3 "'Come on, boys! Let's go get 'em!' he yelled and leaped to his feet motioning the platoon forward. He took two steps, the platoon with their bayonets fixed since early morning right behind him, and fell down dead, stitched diagonally from hip to shoulder by bullets, one which exploded his heart."
Pg. 191 Paragraph 2 "Not as athletic as his fellow worker, but more imaginative, more sensitive, he too leaped up and motioned his men forward, when he saw the 1st platoon move. He could see the whole thing finished in his imagination: himself and Whyte and their men standing atop the bombed out bunkers in proper triumph, the position captured. he too died on the forward slope but not at the crest like Whyte."
Pg. 204 Paragraph 1 "Doll slide his rifle up, raised the sight four clicks, and lying with only his left arm and shoulder outside his little hole, sighted on the man in front, leading him a little, and squeezed off a shot. The rifle bucked his shoulder and the man went down."
Pg. 193 Paragraph 2 "Bell's face was turned left, his cheek pressed to the ground, and he tried not to breathe too conspicuously for the fear of calling attention to himself. Cautiously he opened his eyes, half afraid the movement of his eyelids would be seen by a machine-gunner a hundred yards away, and found himself starring into the open eyes of the 1st platoon's first scout lying dead five yards to Bell' sleft.
Pg. 258 Paragraph 4 "'I'm dying, Captain!' he croaked, rolling his eyes toward Stein. 'I'm dying! Me! Me! I'm dying! I'm so scared!' he closed his eyes moment and swallowed. 'I was just laying there. And it hit me right in the side. Like somebodu punched me. Didn't hurt much. Doesn't hurt much now. Oh, Captain!'"
Ryan Person D
The book discussion went pretty well this week, everybody did their jobs for this week. Everyone this week was very focused and on task. Our group discussed what happened in the last chapter, Mike was going around the group asking the questions that he made, Mitchell did the same and they both posted their questions online. Finally, Nick read us his quotes that he found in the last chapter of the book and we followed along in the book while he read us the quotes. Towards the end of the class, and after we discussed what happened in the book and after everyone read the jobs that the did for homework, everyone began to fool around. Just like what has happened in the last two discussions. So far in all of our book clubs meetings our group has stayed on task and has not fooled around until the meeting begins to end and everyone has read their jobs that they did for homework. Then, at the end everyone fools around. Hopefully for the next meeting everyone stays on task throughout the entire meeting, no one fools around, and everyone in the group contributes to the discussion and gets their work done.
Week 4
Person A-Nick Zevits
The images that is used is fear. Fear is shown through the characters emotions as well as their behavior. One example is when Fife is crawling on the ground while everyone else was crouching. The author tries to show fear because that is a big part of war, which the the main theme of the book.
Person B-Alex Falzarano
“Billions of hard, bright stars shone with relentless glitter all across the tropic night sky. Underneath the brilliant canopy of the universe, the men lay wide awake and waited”
“This lack of water was becoming a serious problem for everybody, and would be more of one as the glaring equatorial sun mounted, but whatever the reason-though there was plenty of water in the rear- no water could be got this far forward to them”
“Stein saw another man (It looked like Big Queen but he couldn’t be sure) advance upon a Japanese man who was grinning desperately with his hands high up in the air, push the rife which carried no bayonet to within an inch of his face and shoot him in the nose.”
“These guys were all slobs, that was the truth. And this Battalion was going to hell on a sled.”
“Everybody had at least three stories of personal, hair raising escape from death stories to tell, and at least two stories of person Jap-killing.”
Mitchell Raver Quotes
1. Off to the left of his disorganized scene was the only bit of sensible organization Stein could see
2. It was indeed Big Queen when Stein had seen him shoot the grinning Japenese man
3. Im relieving you of your command, Stein, he said without Preamble
4. You shouldn't ought to talk to me like you did, Dale growled with authority
5. Well you are a jerk! Witt shouted, scrambling to his feet
Summary Mike Tudisco
Ryan asked his questions first. Many of them were good; they were mostly about emotions or choices. Mitchell then read his quotes witch were mostly about the peoples’ actions. Alex’s quotes were also good with a lot of description. Next we all helped Nick with the questions he had to answer.
The second half of the period we discussed the book and ate lots of delicious brownies baked to perfection by my most wonderful mother, the greatest mother to ever live. We basically summarized what happened in this chapter. After that, we discussed some things we liked and disliked about the book. We said that we did not like how the author would write very descriptive paragraphs that to be honest were boring. We did like the action that was described in the book.
Ryan Patti Questions
1. Would you be nervous and panicky if one of your friends or commander was at a high risk of death in the war?
Answer: Yes, because I would probably be very close to that person that is at risk of death.
2. Would you be upset if your friend did die?
Answer: Yes, because I would be very close to that person.
3. Would you be a leader of your squad and be brave, or would you hang in the middle of the squad and be selfish and not be brave, if you were in the war?
Answer: I would be brave and be a leader because it is never good to be scared and to worry about yourself.
4. If a friend of yours in your squad died right in front of your eyes on a difficultly and life taking mission how would you react?
Answer: I would probably have to take my own life for him because I would feel so bad and I would probably become immediately upset on the spot.
5. Would you be selfish and take all the good guns or would you be considerate and use teamwork with your squad in the war?
Answer: I would use teamwork because that is how most nations win their wars, with teamwork.
week 5
Questions: Alex Falzarano
Did you like the Ending of the Book Ended?
Yes because it was good to know that the people went back to America to their normal lives.
Do you think the soldiers in Charlie Company will be forever changed because of the sights that they saw during the war?
Yes because once you see death you can really forget it. It will stay with you all your life.
Would you care if the ship ride back to the states would be just as long as the first time, or would you just be glad you’re off of Guadalcanal.
I would be glad that I am of Guadalcanal and I wouldn’t think the ride back would be as bad as before because there are many people that died and there would be more space.
Why do you think the book was called the Thin Red Line?
Because on the map of the island there was a thin red line and that was were that Japanese were the strongest and at the end of the book they broke through that line and finally go home.
Did you like the overall book?
No because there was too much detail to unimportant things
MItchell Raver summarizer
Micheal Tudisco did not do his homework and disrupted book club many times and did not not let anyone speak, Mike also went crazy and smashed more cookies and hit my computer with a plastic bin. Ryan Patti just smashed cookies and screamed the whole time. Nick Zevits was very good and read everything properly. Alex Falzarano read everything fine and did not disrupt anyone. Overall it was a very disruptive book club thanks Mike Tudisco and Ryan Patti
Mike Tudisco Quotes “I can’t see to do hardly anything without them.” He deliberately did not say Sir. P. 364
“Yes, Sir. Thank you, Sir,” he said getting up and trying to put all his hatred in his eyes. He left without saluting. P. 365
The most perfect, most perfectly trained soldier could do nothing to protect against, or save himself from, the element of chance. P. 403
He lay and counted one hundred and thirty Japanese pass, biting his fingers and weeping real tears because he had no grenades. P. 458
In his mind he was muttering over and over his old phrase of understanding: “Property. Property. All for property,” which he had once said in rudimentary innocence arriving on this island. P. 510
Questions: Nick Zevits
1. How did you like the ending of the book?
Good, I liked how the surving soldiers were sent how after the brutal fights they went through.
2. If there was a sequal, would you read it? Why or why not?
No, I thought the book was boring because the author explained non-important parts of the book too much. I think any other books written by this author would be written the same way as this book.
3. What did you dislike about the book? What did you like?
I didn't like how the author explained so much about the characters, but I liked the detail used during the battles.
4. What was the best part of the book?
The best part of the book was when C for Charlie was advancing to hill 209. This was one of the battles with great details. When I was reading it, I felt like I was part of the battle.
5. Back in chapter 2, C for Charlie raided the supply tent and took the thompsons. Do you think they helped, Why or why not?
I think the thompsons did help the company because it supplied more fire power to them.
Strike two: for whoever forgets to complete their assignment twice, they get their laptop taken away by Mr. Morone and they have to bring the food and they are also not aloud to eat it.
Strike Three: you get double the work.
Strike Four: lastly if you forget to do your assignment, you get a zero for participation and there names will be written down on this website, so Mr. Morone knows who the person is.
One must stand and sing a song
Weak 1 jobs
Group leader Mitchell
Person C Nick
Summarizer alex
Quotation finder mike Ryan
Weak 2 jobs
Group leader Mike
Person B Michell
person C Ryan Alex Ryan didn't do it
person D Nick
1. The main characters are Doll,Bells, Queen, Feife, Welsh, Stein, Storm, Dale. They are all tough strong willed people who are in the C for charlie squad for a reason, they all treat each other tough like in order to succeed. Doll acts like a tough guy and is like a rebel. Bells was an army engineer in the philippenes and got re-signed. Queen is some one who is very strong. Feife is kind of a coward and Welsh is kind of a strange person. Stein is the captain of the squad. Storm is the cook and takes pride in his work. Dale is one of the cooks who found the thompsons.
2 quotations Mike Tudisco
At any rate, the best way to be injured was to have a wound so bad that you almost die, one that would keep you sick long enough for the
war to be over, but not bad enough to be crippled by.
The explosion itself actually – could be considered the apex from which the line turned down to the bottom and discharge, their secret goal.
In the end, C for Charlie saw three men die in the aid station.
They had crossed a line, they were wounded men, and everyone knew they were different.
And one man, word had it, had his face smashed in by a helmet blown from the head of some man in the barge.
Person 3-Nick Zevits
1. How would you react if you saw someone die right in front of you? What about if you had to kill someone?
Answer: "I would be scared that I might also be shot and be thankful it was not me who died. I would just kill the person because it is my job, and that person is trying to kill me."
2. Do you think it was really worth it for Doll to steal the pistol, why or why not?
Answer: "I think it was good for Doll to steal the pistol because it might help him and his company if they get surprised attacked so he can pull out the pistol easily instead of having to get his rifle."
3. If you found the Japanese burial site, what would you do? Would you let the other soldiers do what they did?
Answer: "If I found the Japanese burial site, I would explore it and see what I find. I would not have let Queen and the other soldiers disrespect the burial ground the way they did."
4. How would you react if your hand was cut off from a missile fragment, and the medics did not really care?
Answer: "I would curse at the medics, and then tell them to throw the hand away because I would hate to look at my own hand that was cut off."
5. Would you have stolen the guns from the tent? Why or why not?
Answer: "I would have stolen the guns from the tent because it is only 7 machine guns and 6 rifles. Also, it could help my company out if we ever got caught in a battle."
Alex Falzarano
The first book club meeting, in my opinion, was a mix between conversation and arguments. Throughout the second half of the conversation, after we settled down and actually started to do what we were supposed to do, everything went relatively smooth. Some of our answers to the questions that Nick gave us were a little choppy. We discussed the main characters in the book, and what their characteristics were in the beginning of the book. In addition, we discussed our opinion on the some of the horrifying obstacles the characters faced in the first 100 hundred pages of the book.
Some of the questions that we were asked were, what would your reaction be if you had just killed someone? Another question that we were asked was, if you had found the Japanese burial site, what would you have done. Would you have let the other soldier do what they did? Despite our minor setbacks in the beginning of the meeting, this first meeting went relatively smooth once we got going. Hopefully by the next meeting everyone will have read there assigned amount of pages, and the next meeting will run smoothly with no interruptions.
Ryan Patti- Quotations
1. "Alright, fuck face! Where's that fucking platoon roster I told you to fix up for me!"(pg 32)
2. Even the army itself understood this about them then wounded, and had made special despensations for their newly accquired honorly status.(pg 47)
3. "Fuck duties!"(pg 60)
4. It had stopped raining when they were in the jungle. But they hadn't known it.(pg 79)
5. Finally it would be a day that they take up their lives once more.(pg 90)
Week 2
discussion leader Mike
1 The grade level is 18 and up. They use the f word a lot and has a few hard to understand words.
The book uses modern language.
Nick Zevits-Person D (Summarizer)
The second book club meeting went a little better than the first. at the beginning of the meeting, we were mostly on task and everyone was listening to the person speaking. This was the first meeting we had to enforce the group's rules. Ryan forgot his homework for the second meeting so we had to take his food away and now he has to do his work for this past week and next week for the third meeting. Noise was not a bad problem at the first half of the meeting, and everyone was contributing to the group. I thought the group was improving a lot better than the last meeting, until everyone was done with sharing their jobs and started typing.
Everyone started fooling around and nothing was getting accomplished. Only one person was able to type their part at a time so everyone was waiting for the person to finish. Since everyone was talking and fooling around, the person did not type as fast as they could and kept everyone else waiting. The only thing that did improve was the commitment of the group members. A lot of food was brought this friday compared to the last friday. It was like a feast with all of our food we had. I hope next week the group picks up their acts including me and hope it goes a lot better than the previous meetings.
Person C- Alex Falzarano
1. Like Fife, would you regret enlisting in World War two, just because you did not want look like a coward in front of your country. Why or Why not? No because I would want to be loyal to my country.
2. Do you think you would have to courage to keep on walking even though you were being fired at by an unknown position, or would you start crawling, like some in the soldiers in Charlie Company did? I would want to craw because I would not want to get shot.
3. When Peale got injured, if you were him, would you want to eventually come back into the war, or not? Yes because you would get drafted back into the war.
4. If you were one of the soldiers who had saw what the Japanese did to the 2 solders from George company, would that make you want to fight harder or no? yes.
5. If you had saw a dead body with a Thompson machine on to of it would you take it why or why not? Yes because it is for the teams benefit.
Week 3
Alex Falzarano person AThe chapter that we read this week had a very sad and dramatic mood. During this chapter, many people of Charlie Company died because of Japanese mortar emplacements, and small arms fire from hidden locations. Bead, one of the main characters in the book, died by getting hit by fragment from a mortal shell. Throughout this chapter everyone was depressed, and constantly thinking about how they might die in any second of their attack on hill 209.
Mike Tudisco Questions
1 What do you think would be the hardest part of serving in the army?
Trying to face the fact that you could die.
2 Why do you think everyone in the army needs to act so “macho”?
They don’t want to be made fun of.
3 What was Doll’s reason for volunteering to go tell Stein that the Japanese were leaving the ridge even thou it was suicide?.
Because he killed someone and had a adrenalin rush.
4 Why did Fife wish he was crazy?
He would have been kicked out of the army.
5 What does Welsh saying, “property, property, all for property”, mean?
Everything is done for land or money.
MItchell raver questions
1. Would you shoot Welsh to put him out of his misery
No, i would not want to kill someone i am friends with
2. Would you disagree with the Captains orders?
Yes, if they are really stupid
3. How would you feel if someone that was only friends with you died?
I would feel terrible and feel for him
4. How would you react to someone getting shot in the war?
I would kind of move on but still be sad
5. Would you proud to be recommended to go up a rank?
Yes because i feel like i have done a good job and helped a lot
Nick Zevits Person B
Pg. 190, Paragraph 3 "'Come on, boys! Let's go get 'em!' he yelled and leaped to his feet motioning the platoon forward. He took two steps, the platoon with their bayonets fixed since early morning right behind him, and fell down dead, stitched diagonally from hip to shoulder by bullets, one which exploded his heart."
Pg. 191 Paragraph 2 "Not as athletic as his fellow worker, but more imaginative, more sensitive, he too leaped up and motioned his men forward, when he saw the 1st platoon move. He could see the whole thing finished in his imagination: himself and Whyte and their men standing atop the bombed out bunkers in proper triumph, the position captured. he too died on the forward slope but not at the crest like Whyte."
Pg. 204 Paragraph 1 "Doll slide his rifle up, raised the sight four clicks, and lying with only his left arm and shoulder outside his little hole, sighted on the man in front, leading him a little, and squeezed off a shot. The rifle bucked his shoulder and the man went down."
Pg. 193 Paragraph 2 "Bell's face was turned left, his cheek pressed to the ground, and he tried not to breathe too conspicuously for the fear of calling attention to himself. Cautiously he opened his eyes, half afraid the movement of his eyelids would be seen by a machine-gunner a hundred yards away, and found himself starring into the open eyes of the 1st platoon's first scout lying dead five yards to Bell' sleft.
Pg. 258 Paragraph 4 "'I'm dying, Captain!' he croaked, rolling his eyes toward Stein. 'I'm dying! Me! Me! I'm dying! I'm so scared!' he closed his eyes moment and swallowed. 'I was just laying there. And it hit me right in the side. Like somebodu punched me. Didn't hurt much. Doesn't hurt much now. Oh, Captain!'"
Ryan Person D
The book discussion went pretty well this week, everybody did their jobs for this week. Everyone this week was very focused and on task. Our group discussed what happened in the last chapter, Mike was going around the group asking the questions that he made, Mitchell did the same and they both posted their questions online. Finally, Nick read us his quotes that he found in the last chapter of the book and we followed along in the book while he read us the quotes. Towards the end of the class, and after we discussed what happened in the book and after everyone read the jobs that the did for homework, everyone began to fool around. Just like what has happened in the last two discussions. So far in all of our book clubs meetings our group has stayed on task and has not fooled around until the meeting begins to end and everyone has read their jobs that they did for homework. Then, at the end everyone fools around. Hopefully for the next meeting everyone stays on task throughout the entire meeting, no one fools around, and everyone in the group contributes to the discussion and gets their work done.
Week 4
Person A-Nick Zevits
The images that is used is fear. Fear is shown through the characters emotions as well as their behavior. One example is when Fife is crawling on the ground while everyone else was crouching. The author tries to show fear because that is a big part of war, which the the main theme of the book.
Person B-Alex Falzarano
“Billions of hard, bright stars shone with relentless glitter all across the tropic night sky. Underneath the brilliant canopy of the universe, the men lay wide awake and waited”
“This lack of water was becoming a serious problem for everybody, and would be more of one as the glaring equatorial sun mounted, but whatever the reason-though there was plenty of water in the rear- no water could be got this far forward to them”
“Stein saw another man (It looked like Big Queen but he couldn’t be sure) advance upon a Japanese man who was grinning desperately with his hands high up in the air, push the rife which carried no bayonet to within an inch of his face and shoot him in the nose.”
“These guys were all slobs, that was the truth. And this Battalion was going to hell on a sled.”
“Everybody had at least three stories of personal, hair raising escape from death stories to tell, and at least two stories of person Jap-killing.”
Mitchell Raver Quotes
1. Off to the left of his disorganized scene was the only bit of sensible organization Stein could see
2. It was indeed Big Queen when Stein had seen him shoot the grinning Japenese man
3. Im relieving you of your command, Stein, he said without Preamble
4. You shouldn't ought to talk to me like you did, Dale growled with authority
5. Well you are a jerk! Witt shouted, scrambling to his feet
Summary Mike Tudisco
Ryan asked his questions first. Many of them were good; they were mostly about emotions or choices. Mitchell then read his quotes witch were mostly about the peoples’ actions. Alex’s quotes were also good with a lot of description. Next we all helped Nick with the questions he had to answer.
The second half of the period we discussed the book and ate lots of delicious brownies baked to perfection by my most wonderful mother, the greatest mother to ever live. We basically summarized what happened in this chapter. After that, we discussed some things we liked and disliked about the book. We said that we did not like how the author would write very descriptive paragraphs that to be honest were boring. We did like the action that was described in the book.
Ryan Patti Questions
1. Would you be nervous and panicky if one of your friends or commander was at a high risk of death in the war?
Answer: Yes, because I would probably be very close to that person that is at risk of death.
2. Would you be upset if your friend did die?
Answer: Yes, because I would be very close to that person.
3. Would you be a leader of your squad and be brave, or would you hang in the middle of the squad and be selfish and not be brave, if you were in the war?
Answer: I would be brave and be a leader because it is never good to be scared and to worry about yourself.
4. If a friend of yours in your squad died right in front of your eyes on a difficultly and life taking mission how would you react?
Answer: I would probably have to take my own life for him because I would feel so bad and I would probably become immediately upset on the spot.
5. Would you be selfish and take all the good guns or would you be considerate and use teamwork with your squad in the war?
Answer: I would use teamwork because that is how most nations win their wars, with teamwork.
week 5
Questions: Alex Falzarano
Did you like the Ending of the Book Ended?
Yes because it was good to know that the people went back to America to their normal lives.
Do you think the soldiers in Charlie Company will be forever changed because of the sights that they saw during the war?
Yes because once you see death you can really forget it. It will stay with you all your life.
Would you care if the ship ride back to the states would be just as long as the first time, or would you just be glad you’re off of Guadalcanal.
I would be glad that I am of Guadalcanal and I wouldn’t think the ride back would be as bad as before because there are many people that died and there would be more space.
Why do you think the book was called the Thin Red Line?
Because on the map of the island there was a thin red line and that was were that Japanese were the strongest and at the end of the book they broke through that line and finally go home.
Did you like the overall book?
No because there was too much detail to unimportant things
MItchell Raver summarizer
Micheal Tudisco did not do his homework and disrupted book club many times and did not not let anyone speak, Mike also went crazy and smashed more cookies and hit my computer with a plastic bin. Ryan Patti just smashed cookies and screamed the whole time. Nick Zevits was very good and read everything properly. Alex Falzarano read everything fine and did not disrupt anyone. Overall it was a very disruptive book club thanks Mike Tudisco and Ryan Patti
Mike Tudisco Quotes
“I can’t see to do hardly anything without them.” He deliberately did not say Sir.
P. 364
“Yes, Sir. Thank you, Sir,” he said getting up and trying to put all his hatred in his eyes. He left without saluting.
P. 365
The most perfect, most perfectly trained soldier could do nothing to protect against, or save himself from, the element of chance.
P. 403
He lay and counted one hundred and thirty Japanese pass, biting his fingers and weeping real tears because he had no grenades.
P. 458
In his mind he was muttering over and over his old phrase of understanding: “Property. Property. All for property,” which he had once said in rudimentary innocence arriving on this island.
P. 510
Questions: Nick Zevits
1. How did you like the ending of the book?
Good, I liked how the surving soldiers were sent how after the brutal fights they went through.
2. If there was a sequal, would you read it? Why or why not?
No, I thought the book was boring because the author explained non-important parts of the book too much. I think any other books written by this author would be written the same way as this book.
3. What did you dislike about the book? What did you like?
I didn't like how the author explained so much about the characters, but I liked the detail used during the battles.
4. What was the best part of the book?
The best part of the book was when C for Charlie was advancing to hill 209. This was one of the battles with great details. When I was reading it, I felt like I was part of the battle.
5. Back in chapter 2, C for Charlie raided the supply tent and took the thompsons. Do you think they helped, Why or why not?
I think the thompsons did help the company because it supplied more fire power to them.